Systems Engineering FAQ

Answers by Robert Halligan FIE Aust CPEng IntPE(Aus).

Home » Resources » FAQs » What are the pros & cons of SCRUM?

What are the pros & cons of SCRUM?

Posted October 4, 2022

Question

SCRUM is an iterative and incremental agile software development method for managing software projects and conducting product or application development. What are the pros & cons of SCRUM? Does it really shorten product development?

Answer

A comparison by Capers Jones of ten different software development methodologies including Agile/SCRUM2 was published in Project Performance International’s (PPI’s) System Engineering News Letter (SyEN), January 2012, viewable and downloadable at http://www.ppi-int.com/newsletter/systems-engineering-newsletter.php.

The comparison is based on very extensive hard data (let me know if you need the full set of data sources).

The conclusion: agile/SCRUM2 is very good on time and initial development cost, but performs relatively poorly on software quality and software cost of ownership over 5 years. Software cost of ownership includes the cost of fixing design/coding errors and defective requirements after software release.

Team Software Process – TSP performs almost as well as agile/SCRUM2 on time and initial development cost, and comes out way ahead of the field with respect to software quality and cost of ownership. TSP is a Watts Humphrey SEI integration of facets of agile, extreme programming, formal inspections, and other approaches.

Robert Halligan

Connected on LinkedIn

Systems engineering thought leader, consultant, trainer and coach, impacting people's lives on six continents.

Published 2 years ago

Why Recognition of Profit, not Imposition of Process, Will Ultimately Bring Systems Engineering Into Common Usage

What Factors Hold Back the Widespread Practice of Systems Engineering? Randall Iliff explores this fascinating question in the April 2023 issue of PPI SyEN. His perspective as a founding member of INCOSE and current PPI Principal Consultant offers unusual clarity regarding the challenges we face […]

Why Recognition of Profit, not Imposition of Process, Will Ultimately Bring Systems Engineering Into Common Usage Read More »

Form Follows Function – A Gem of Wisdom

Professionals from various technology and application domains and of different experience levels discuss Form and Function, here are my thoughts …

Form Follows Function – A Gem of Wisdom Read More »

3 Systems Engineering Tools That Can Change a Company

I share with you today three process tools (amongst many others that exist) that I’ve developed and used extensively over the years, and that can really make a difference […]

3 Systems Engineering Tools That Can Change a Company Read More »

Do you have any advice on systems engineering standard ISO/IEC 15288 (IEEE Std 15288-2008) – 2nd Edition “Systems and software engineering – Systems Life Cycle Processes”?

Are there legitimate opportunities to use Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) to reduce the Verification & Validation burden in the implementation? Where are the risks in doing so?

What is Systems Engineering?

Why do you not recommend Quality Function Deployment (QFD)?

What is the relationship between a System Requirements Specification, an Operational Concept Description, and a System/Subsystem Design Description?

Are your overall comments related to ISO/IEC 15288: 2008 (in the FAQ section) still applicable to the 2015 revision, or have most of the shortcomings been addressed?

What is the relationship between systems engineering and configuration management?

How do we achieve interoperability?

Do you have any advice on the use of ISO/IEC 15288 (IEEE Std 15288-2008), Second Edition 2008-02-01, Systems and software engineering – System Life Cycle Processes?

What are the various types of interface information used in systems and software engineering, and how do these types of information relate to one another?

Is Systems Engineering applicable in an applied research environment?

Do you have any comments on the book “Managing Complex Technical Projects” by R Ian Faulconbridge and Michael J Ryan, ISBN 1-58053-378-7

What are Interface Requirements Specifications, Interface Design Descriptions, Interface Control Documents, and how do they relate?

What is the Basis of Justifiable Verification Costs?

What is the difference between an Operational Concept Description (OCD) and a Concept of Operations (CONOPS)?

Do you have any application advice on ECSS-E-ST-10C, 6 March 2009, titled “Space engineering – System engineering general requirements”, from the European Space Agency?

Systems Engineering FAQ

What are the pros & cons of SCRUM?

Question

Answer

Answered By

Advance your career

Reduce rework

Drive innovation with PPI

Enhance and develop your skills

Build a better team

Sharpen your skills

Become a better engineer

Set yourself apart with PPI’s world-leading training

Subscribe to PPI SyEN

Related Articles

More Frequently Asked Questions